Delightful Overnight French Toast

As seen in: Pancakes, Waffles & French Toast: Breakfast Classics Reinvented

Transform ordinary bread into a decadent breakfast by letting it soak overnight in sweet vanilla custard and finishing with a crispy nut topping. Prep before bed for easy mornings.
iamcooker.com
Refreshed on Wed, 09 Apr 2025 19:14:34 GMT
A close-up of a baked dessert in a white dish, topped with crumbled nuts and powdered sugar, with some portions visible and plates in the background. Save it
A close-up of a baked dessert in a white dish, topped with crumbled nuts and powdered sugar, with some portions visible and plates in the background. | iamcooker.com

I've gotta tell you about my go-to morning bake that transforms basic French toast into something extraordinary! Through countless family get-togethers, I've tweaked this dish to perfection, mixing custardy bread with an irresistible crunchy topping. My family starts begging for it way before any holiday rolls around.

Magic Happens With The Bread

Wanna know the game-changer for this breakfast bake? It's all about using sourdough! I found out its firm structure and subtle tartness makes the ideal foundation. It stands up nicely to the rich custard without turning soggy like regular bread tends to. Can't track down sourdough? A nice crusty Italian bread works great too.

What You'll Need

  • The Base: A pound of sourdough ripped into mouth-watering chunks.
  • For The Velvety Custard:
    • 8 eggs for that smooth texture
    • 3 cups half-and-half making everything ultra creamy
    • Cozy spices including cinnamon and nutmeg
    • Quality vanilla that truly enhances everything
  • The Incredible Topping:
    • Butter that's soft but still firm
    • Brown sugar creating that caramel-like sweetness
    • Pecans broken up for amazing texture
    • A bit of flour to bind everything together

Creating Your Morning Masterpiece

Setup Time
Grab your largest baking dish and spray it down. Then break that bread into pieces - I actually prefer varying sizes for better texture contrast.
Custard Creation
Now comes the fun part! Beat those eggs with half-and-half, vanilla, brown sugar and all those warm spices until it looks silky smooth. Pour this mixture over your bread chunks so they're all nicely soaked.
The Waiting Game
Here's my trick for incredible texture: let everything sit in your fridge overnight. The bread will drink up all that wonderful custard completely.
Crumbly Goodness
Combine your nuts, flour, brown sugar and butter until you see little clumps forming. Think of it as better-than-pie streusel!
Baking Time
Scatter all that crumbly mix on your soaked bread and bake until you see it puff up with a golden surface. Your home will smell absolutely incredible!

Dishing It Up Beautifully

Want to take this dish to the next level? Serve it while it's warm with real maple syrup drizzled across and a light sprinkling of powdered sugar. I always add some fresh berries for color and brightness. It's absolutely perfect for slow weekend mornings or big family celebrations.

Storage Smarts

Let me tell you what I've figured out about storing leftovers, though they rarely last in my house! This bake stays good in the fridge for around four days. Just wrap it properly and when you're hungry again, warm it in the oven to maintain that crispy topping. The microwave works if you're rushed but the oven truly brings back that just-baked quality.

Customize Your Creation

I've got some fun twists you might enjoy! Sometimes I'll mix in some orange zest for a bright flavor or toss in chocolate chips when the kids are around. Feeling like something savory? Just skip all sweet stuff and toss in herbs, cheese and veggies instead. It's basically a new dish every time you make it!

A baked dessert with golden-brown pieces topped with a crumbly mixture and chopped nuts, served in a white dish. Save it
A baked dessert with golden-brown pieces topped with a crumbly mixture and chopped nuts, served in a white dish. | iamcooker.com

Fantastic Topping Tricks

You know what truly sets this breakfast bake apart? That buttery, nutty topping! Make sure you're using cold butter when mixing it up - you'll get those perfect little chunks that way. And spread it all over evenly so nobody misses out on that wonderful crunchiness in their serving.

Smart Prep For Gatherings

Here's my top hosting shortcut: put this together the night before your big event. Just keep that crumbly topping separate in the fridge. When morning comes, you just need to sprinkle the topping on and stick it in the oven. Your company will wake up to the most wonderful breakfast smells ever!

Nailing The Right Consistency

Let me share how to get that perfect custardy feel every single time. Those random-sized sourdough chunks create little pockets that trap the custard beautifully. Some bits turn super soft while others stay slightly chewy, giving you an amazing mix of textures with each forkful.

Elevating Breakfast Time

This isn't just food - it's a whole morning moment! I love watching warm maple syrup sink into all those little crevices. Pair it with some crunchy bacon and colorful fresh berries. When my family sees this coming out of the oven, they know they're in for something awesome!

Keeping It Fresh

My best advice for leftovers: cover them tightly and they'll taste great from the fridge for up to four days. When you want more, put it in the oven with some foil on top. About 15 minutes at 350 makes it taste fresh-baked again. You can use your microwave if you're short on time, but the oven really keeps that topping nice and crunchy.

Adjusting To Your Needs

The cool thing about this dish? How easily you can change it up! Need to skip dairy? Try almond milk and coconut cream instead of half-and-half. Want less sweetness? Just use less brown sugar. Friends have even made it with gluten-free bread with great results. It's all about making it work for your own table.

A slice of baked French toast topped with chopped nuts and sprinkled with powdered sugar, served with a drizzle of syrup on a white plate. Save it
A slice of baked French toast topped with chopped nuts and sprinkled with powdered sugar, served with a drizzle of syrup on a white plate. | iamcooker.com

Smart Tricks For Perfect Results

Let me share my final tips for an amazing French toast bake. Always gently push the bread into your custard so each piece gets properly soaked. If the top starts browning too fast while cooking, just cover it loosely with foil. And don't forget to let it cool for about 10 minutes after baking - it'll be easier to serve and won't burn anyone's mouth!

Common Questions

→ Can I use different types of bread?
Most hearty breads work fine, but don't go for baguettes. Try sourdough, Italian, or French loaves for the best results.
→ How far ahead can I prepare this?
You can put it together up to 24 hours before and keep it in the fridge. The longer it sits, the more custardy it'll get.
→ Can I skip the overnight soak?
If you're in a rush, let it sit out for about an hour before baking. It won't be as rich as the overnight version though.
→ What nuts work best in the topping?
We like pecans or walnuts the most, but any chopped nuts will do the trick. Feel free to mix different kinds too.
→ How do I know when it's done?
You'll see it puff up with a golden brown top, and the middle should be set. This usually takes around 45-50 minutes in the oven.

Baked French Toast

An easy prep-ahead breakfast featuring torn bread chunks soaked in creamy custard, finished with a crunchy, buttery topping. Just right for lazy mornings.

Preparation
20 Mins
Cooking Duration
50 Mins
Complete Duration
70 Mins
By: sofia


Complexity: Moderate

Origin: American

Output: 8 Portions (1 9x13 casserole)

Diet Types: Plant-Based (with dairy/eggs)

What You'll Need

01 4 tablespoons butter, unsalted
02 1 pound of Italian or sourdough bread
03 8 large eggs
04 3 cups half-and-half
05 3/4 cup brown sugar, light
06 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
07 1 teaspoon cinnamon, ground
08 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt
09 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg, ground
10 2 ounces nuts, chopped
11 1/4 cup flour, all-purpose
12 Maple syrup for topping
13 Fresh berries for garnish

Preparation Steps

01 Step

Spray a 9x13-inch baking dish with non-stick cooking spray

02 Step

Rip bread into small chunks and place them in the baking dish

03 Step

Beat eggs with half-and-half, brown sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, salt and nutmeg until completely combined

04 Step

Pour the egg mixture over bread, gently push bread down, wrap and chill in fridge overnight

05 Step

Combine nuts, flour, brown sugar, spices and butter until it forms small crumbles

06 Step

Sprinkle crumble on top and cook at 350°F for about 45-50 minutes until it turns golden brown

Additional Tips

  1. You can make this up to a day ahead
  2. Bread needs to soak for at least an hour
  3. Feel free to switch up the bread type or nut variety

Required Equipment

  • Baking dish (9x13-inch)
  • Bowls for mixing
  • Whisk
  • Plastic wrap

Allergen Notice

Review ingredients for possible allergens and seek professional medical advice if uncertain.
  • Dairy
  • Eggs
  • Wheat
  • Tree nuts

Nutritional Information (Each Portion)

Consider these values as estimates rather than definitive health guidance.
  • Energy: 380
  • Fat Content: 18 g
  • Carbohydrates: 45 g
  • Protein Content: 12 g