Save it
This twist on tuna salad dumps the mayo and brings in cottage cheese instead. You'll get amazing creamy, tangy, and crunchy bites with a whopping 29 grams of protein in each serving. We've thrown in fresh herbs, tangy lemon, and crisp veggies for a tasty meal that's good for you and truly satisfying.
I made this while prepping meals for a crazy week ahead. My teenage kid, who always turns his nose up at anything "healthy," went back for more and wanted it in his school lunch. The trick? I blended the cottage cheese until it was totally smooth - you'd never know it wasn't mayo!
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Cottage cheese: Go for small curd, full-fat for the smoothest blend
- Canned tuna: Solid white albacore has better chunks and milder taste
- Red onion: Pick ones that feel heavy and soak the chopped bits in cold water to take away the bite
- Celery: Look for bright green, snappy stalks for extra crunch
- Dill pickles: Buy whole, crisp pickles and chop them yourself for better flavor
- Fresh garlic: Get firm cloves and chop them right before you use them
- Fresh lemon: Choose ones that feel heavy with smooth, bright skin
- Fresh herbs: Make sure they look bright and perky, not wilted
Simple Step-by-Step Mixing Guide
- Step 1:
- Get Your Base Ready: Pour off extra liquid from cottage cheese. Use a blender to make it completely smooth. Keep a little extra aside to fix consistency later. Add salt and pepper as you like. Wait 5 minutes for flavors to mix.
- Step 2:
- Fix Your Tuna: Drain it really well, squeezing out all water. Break it up with a fork into small bits. Look for any hidden bones. Leave some bigger chunks for texture.
- Step 3:
- Mix Everything Up: Start with tuna and smooth cottage cheese. Add chopped veggies bit by bit. Gently stir in herbs and spices. Make it wetter or drier as needed. Let it sit so flavors can blend.
Save it
At our family picnic last week, I brought this tuna salad along. It held up great in the cooler for hours and tasted just as good. Everyone was shocked when I told them there wasn't any mayo in it - they couldn't tell the difference from the regular stuff!
Prep Ahead Tricks
Cut up your veggies and keep them separate from the tuna mix to keep everything fresh longer. This stops the veggies from getting soft and keeps their crunch. When you're ready to eat, just throw everything together and tweak the seasoning.
Ways to Enjoy It
This versatile mix can become different meals all week long. Stuff it in whole grain pitas, wrap it in lettuce leaves, or put it on cucumber slices if you're watching carbs. For a protein-packed snack, grab some whole grain crackers or fresh veggie sticks to dip.
Fun Twists to Try
The basic mix can handle lots of changes. Try adding chopped apple for sweetness, a dash of curry powder for warmth, or some capers for tang. Want even more protein? Mix in some chopped hard-boiled eggs. Each change gives you a new taste while keeping all that good protein.
Save it
This protein-packed tuna mix has become my favorite lunch. It shows that healthier choices can taste just as good as the classics - sometimes even better! Whether you need more protein, want to skip mayo, or just need quick meal prep ideas, this'll do the trick on all counts.
Common Questions
- → Why pick cottage cheese over mayo?
- Cottage cheese boosts protein content and maintains creaminess, making it a healthier choice than mayo.
- → Should I always blend the cottage cheese?
- Not at all, you can keep the cottage cheese chunky if that's what you like.
- → How many days can I keep this tuna mix?
- When kept in a sealed container in your fridge, it stays good for 3-4 days.
- → Which tuna gives the best results?
- White albacore tuna works great because it's firm and has a gentle flavor.
- → Can I throw in other veggies?
- Absolutely, try adding cucumber slices, chopped bell peppers, or any crunchy vegetables you like.