Homemade Pie Recipes: From Perfect Crusts to Heavenly Fillings

Few homemade desserts earn the same reverence as a perfectly executed pie, with its combination of flaky crust and flavorful filling creating an eating experience that's greater than the sum of its parts. This collection aims to demystify the art of pie-making, providing both foundational techniques and specific recipes that build confidence in bakers of all levels. We begin with comprehensive guidance on creating different types of pie crusts - from all-butter to shortening blends, from traditional to gluten-free - with step-by-step instructions and troubleshooting advice. From that foundation, the collection expands into a seasonal journey through America's pie traditions, from summer fruit pies bursting with berry flavors to autumn classics showcasing apples and pumpkins, from rich holiday pecan and chocolate pies to refreshing chilled pies for warmer months. The collection also explores the savory side of pie-making, with recipes for hearty main dish pies and quiches that transform simple ingredients into satisfying meals. Throughout, we emphasize the techniques that lead to pie success - proper chilling, correct thickening methods, accurate baking temperatures - while encouraging the seasonal adaptations and personal touches that make each pie unique.

17 findings within this collection. (Page 1 From 2)
Refreshed on Sun, 09 Mar 2025 05:19:37 GMT

Homemade Pie Recipes

A rich slice topped with clouds of whipped cream and chunks of crumble on a pretty plate.

Creamy Peanut Butter Pie

Layers of peanut butter cream, loads of whipped topping, and nutty crumbles fill a light, flaky base.

Check it out Pie Perfection

Pastry rolls filled with lemony cream and topped with meringue, plus some lemon slices alongside.

Lemon Meringue Pie Cannolis

Crunchy pie crust gets stuffed with silky lemon meringue. It’s a snap to put together and feels a little fancy.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A white plate with a slice of pie topped with whipped cream and cinnamon, a whole pie, and drinks visible in the background.

Potato Pie Delight

A smooth and rich dessert, made with sweet potatoes, cozy spices, and a hint of bourbon. Finished with a fluffy bourbon cream for an elegant touch.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A slice of rich, golden pecan pie on a plate with a whole pie in the background.

Southern Pecan Pie

This golden pie pairs bold, nutty pecans with a sweet, buttery filling made with dark syrup and a touch of spice.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A decadent slice of chocolate pecan pie with whipped cream on a plate and a few scattered pecans.

Bourbon Chocolate Pie

A rich mashup of chocolate, bourbon, and sweet pecans, all baked into a silky smooth filling.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A golden slice of apple pie with a flaky lattice crust, baked apples visible inside, served on a plate with an apple in the background.

Flaky Apple Pie

Classic spiced apples sit under a golden, buttery crust. Pre-cooking the apples keeps the texture spot-on and the flavor irresistible.

Check it out Pie Perfection

Creamy pie slice with a golden caramel top, blueberries, and fresh mint sprig, plated beautifully.

Crème Brûlée Pie

An indulgent twist combining the creamy magic of crème brûlée with a golden pie crust and crackling caramel surface.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A slice of pumpkin dessert topped with whipped cream and chocolate, sitting on a gray plate with a fork nearby.

Pumpkin Cheesecake No-Bake

This light, pumpkin dessert sits on a spiced gingersnap base, no oven needed. A superb fall-themed treat for any gathering.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A whipped cream-topped pumpkin pie slice on a decorative plate with a full pie and jar nearby.

Sweet Potato Pie Treat

This sweet potato pie has a rich and smooth spiced filling, a flaky crust, and bourbon-flavored whipped cream. Great for celebrations or anytime.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A creamy slice of pie crowned with whipped cream and caramel, served on a plate with a fork by its side.

Rich Butterscotch Pie

A buttery crust filled with silky butterscotch pudding and piled high with whipped cream. Perfect for prepping ahead for parties.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A close-up of a single slice of pecan pie with a creamy bottom and caramel-colored topping.

Southern Pecan Pie

This buttery pie has a gooey, sweet middle loaded with pecans. It's perfect for any celebration or family get-together.

Check it out Pie Perfection

A plate stacked with golden brown pastries dusted with sugar, one cut open to show an apple-cinnamon filling inside.

Easy Apple Pie Bombs

Simple apple-filled treats using canned biscuits and pie filling, finished with buttery cinnamon sugar and cooked in an air fryer.

Check it out Pie Perfection