Save it
This sweet potato pie transports me straight to my grandma's cooking space. That airy, fluffy center filled with warming spices works its magic with each mouthful. While many folks go for pumpkin at gatherings, I always dish up this down-home favorite on my holiday spread. Just add a spoonful of whiskey-laced whipped topping and you've got something truly divine.
Why This Pie Stands Out
The beauty of this dessert comes from its remarkably fluffy consistency and built-in sweetness. The sweet potatoes deliver such a subtle taste that even my friends who love pumpkin desserts always want more. It fills me with happiness watching visitors try it for their first time, particularly when they notice how it differs from typical festive treats.
Key Components
- 3 large sweet potatoes: Go for the ones with orange insides and coppery skin as they pack the most flavor and give that beautiful hue.
- 1 buttery pie crust: I've got my own version that works great, but grabbing one from the store helps when holiday chaos hits.
- Your favorite spices: My mix includes 2 teaspoons cinnamon, 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg, and a dash of real vanilla.
- 3 large eggs and 1 can evaporated milk: This combo makes that velvety smooth filling we all crave.
- Bourbon whipped cream: Adding just a tiny bit to your cream takes this dessert to another level.
Cooking Instructions
- Prep Your Potatoes
- Stick those sweet potatoes in the microwave for quick cooking, usually about 10 minutes does the trick. This method keeps them from getting too wet.
- Sort Out Your Base
- Put parchment in your cold crust, toss in some weights and give it a short prebake until it looks slightly gold.
- Mix Your Center
- Combine your cooked potatoes with eggs, milk, butter and all those tasty spices until everything looks smooth as silk.
- Into The Oven
- Drop that tasty filling into your crust and cook until it firms up nicely. Cool it down for a couple hours before cutting.
My Cooking Tips
Using your microwave works wonders for cooking sweet potatoes fast without making them soggy. Don't skip prebaking your crust for that crisp bottom everyone loves. Always let your finished pie cool all the way before putting it in the fridge to keep the texture just perfect.
Storage Advice
This treat will stay good in your fridge for about four days if you wrap it up tight. You can eat it cold or let it warm up a bit, whatever you like best. Don't forget that splash of bourbon in your whipped cream topping for that extra touch.
Comforting Southern Treat
This pie adds something truly memorable to your holiday sweet table. Its light custard middle and cozy spices bring real comfort in every bite. After your first taste, you'll see why this southern classic has shown up at family gatherings for so many years.
Save it
Common Questions
- → Why use the microwave for sweet potatoes?
It’s faster, cutting the time to 10 minutes instead of the usual 45+ in the oven. Microwaving ensures even texture, keeps nutrients intact better than boiling, and saves energy.
- → Can I skip using bourbon?
Totally! Leave it out without compromising the texture. Swap for an extra splash of vanilla in the filling and top with plain whipped cream. The spices still make it delicious.
- → What’s the point of blind baking the crust?
This step keeps the base crisp by stopping the wet filling from soaking it. It ensures a nice firm base that contrasts perfectly with the creamy middle and holds firm when sliced.
- → How do I tell if it’s ready?
The edges should be firm, but the center will have a gentle jiggle, like set jelly. Shake the pie lightly; the center should wobble slightly as one piece. As it cools, it’ll firm up fully.
- → Can this be prepped ahead of time?
You can bake it up to two days before and store it in the fridge, though the crust softens a bit. The whipped cream is best made fresh to keep it fluffy and light.