Save it
Down-to-earth but totally delicious, this mushroom pasta brings together earthy mushroom flavors and zesty garlic in a smooth, buttery sauce. Fresh lemon cuts through the richness, while the Parmesan adds a mouthwatering savory kick that'll keep you coming back for more.
I've thrown this together countless times for quick Tuesday dinners and fancy get-togethers too. It's one of those dishes that's super easy but still wows everyone. Just wait for those mushrooms to turn that beautiful golden color - trust me, it's worth being patient.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Cremini Mushrooms: Go for solid, same-sized mushrooms with dry, clean caps. Skip any that feel wet or show darker patches.
- Pappardelle: The broad shape of these noodles grabs onto the sauce beautifully. Try to find ones made with eggs for extra richness.
- Parmesan Cheese: Get a chunk and grate it yourself - the stuff in containers just won't melt right in your sauce.
- Fresh Parsley: Pick bunches that look vibrant green and stand up straight. Don't toss the stems - they pack extra flavor.
- Dijon Mustard: Grab the real French stuff for that perfect tangy bite that makes mushrooms taste even better.
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1: Getting Pasta Just Right
- Make your water taste as salty as ocean water. Give your pasta a good stir right after dropping it in so it doesn't clump together. Keep checking for that perfect al dente bite - you want a tiny bit of firmness left. Save some cooking water before draining - it's the secret to amazing sauce.
- Step 2: Cooking Mushrooms to Perfection
- Give those mushrooms plenty of room in the pan. Try not to fiddle with them too much. You'll see liquid come out first, then wait for it to cook away. They're ready when you spot those gorgeous golden edges.
- Step 3: Building Your Dreamy Sauce
- Cook that garlic just until you can smell it - any longer and it gets bitter. Mix your Dijon in slowly so it blends smoothly. Let everything bubble just enough to thicken slightly. Splash in pasta water bit by bit while stirring until it looks just right.
Save it
I grew up in an Italian family where we learned that simple pasta needs top-notch ingredients. My mom always told me that when your dish has fewer components, each one matters more. The mushrooms especially need to be super fresh - they're the real star here.
What makes this dish so special is how straightforward it is. Every time I cook it, I can't get over how a few basic ingredients turn into something that tastes so fancy.
Save it
This pasta has become my ultimate comfort food go-to. Whether I'm eating alone or feeding a bunch of friends, it always hits the spot with its uncomplicated approach and deep, satisfying taste.
Common Questions
- → What mushrooms work best?
- Cremini mushrooms give the best flavor, but regular white or chopped portobello will do fine too.
- → Can I use different pasta shapes?
- Sure, any medium-sized pasta goes great with this sauce. You can try penne, farfalle, or spirals.
- → Why add Dijon mustard?
- It brings extra flavor and a slight zing that makes the mushroom taste even better.
- → Can I make this ahead?
- It's tastiest right after cooking since the noodles soak up the sauce when left sitting.
- → How do I make it creamier?
- Pour in some heavy cream along with the broth to get a thicker, richer sauce.