Homemade Pie Recipes: From Perfect Crusts to Heavenly Fillings

Few homemade desserts earn the same reverence as a perfectly executed pie, with its combination of flaky crust and flavorful filling creating an eating experience that's greater than the sum of its parts. This collection aims to demystify the art of pie-making, providing both foundational techniques and specific recipes that build confidence in bakers of all levels. We begin with comprehensive guidance on creating different types of pie crusts - from all-butter to shortening blends, from traditional to gluten-free - with step-by-step instructions and troubleshooting advice. From that foundation, the collection expands into a seasonal journey through America's pie traditions, from summer fruit pies bursting with berry flavors to autumn classics showcasing apples and pumpkins, from rich holiday pecan and chocolate pies to refreshing chilled pies for warmer months. The collection also explores the savory side of pie-making, with recipes for hearty main dish pies and quiches that transform simple ingredients into satisfying meals. Throughout, we emphasize the techniques that lead to pie success - proper chilling, correct thickening methods, accurate baking temperatures - while encouraging the seasonal adaptations and personal touches that make each pie unique.

4 findings within this collection.
Refreshed on Sun, 09 Mar 2025 05:19:37 GMT

Homemade Pie Recipes

Chocolate Cream Pie
Dark Chocolate Pie

A stunning dark chocolate pie with a crunchy cookie base, silky homemade chocolate filling, and fluffy whipped cream on top. Everything made from the ground up.

A golden, flaky pastry topped with fresh thyme sits over a creamy chicken and vegetable filling of peas and carrots on a white plate.
Chicken Pie with Puff Pastry

An easy take on traditional chicken pot pie using store-bought pastry as the top layer, packed with creamy chicken and veggie filling.

Peanut Butter Pie
Silky PB Chocolate Pie

A velvety peanut butter mixture on chocolate base, finished with Reese's cups and melted chocolate. The filling doesn't need any oven time.

Spinach Cheese Pie
Spinach Cheese Pie

Rich spinach pie with three cheeses and flaky pastry.