Save it
My family can't get enough of this Sunday Pot Roast Sauce. There's something almost magical about how the beef breaks down into that tomato gravy, mixing with spicy sausage chunks over thick rigatoni tubes. Whenever I cook this, the smell takes over the house and draws everyone to eat without even calling them.
What Makes This Extra Special
This dish turns ordinary pot roast into something you won't forget. The long cooking time builds amazing flavor layers while saving you money. It's my number one pick when I need to feed lots of people, and the best part? The leftover sauce tastes even better the next day.
Everything You Need
- Chuck Roast: This cut gets super soft and packs tons of taste.
- Italian Sausage: I shape these into small bite-sized balls.
- Fresh Vegetables: They build the backbone of flavor.
- Herbs: Both dried and fresh for wonderful smells.
- Good Tomatoes: Try to grab San Marzano for best results.
- Tomato Paste: Adds that intense flavor boost.
- Red Wine: Gives the sauce more depth.
- Rigatoni: These hollow tubes grab sauce perfectly.
- Finishing Touches: Cream, butter and parmesan create that smooth richness.
Let's Start Cooking
- Setting Up
- First I season those beef chunks really well and put them in my Dutch oven along with those tiny sausage balls I rolled.
- Building Layers
- Next come all the veggies and herbs, making the kitchen smell amazing before we even turn on the heat.
- Time for Magic
- Then we let everything simmer for four hours until it transforms completely. Sometimes I make it a day early since it tastes even better after sitting overnight.
- Bringing it Together
- While pasta boils, I pull apart the soft beef and mix it back into the sauce.
- Final Touch
- Mixing in cream, butter and cheese at the end makes everything come together beautifully.
Save it
Planning Ahead
What I really like about this sauce is how much it makes. We'll have it for dinner, then I'll pack away leftovers in containers for the fridge or freezer. It's like giving myself a gift for busy weeknights when I don't want to cook from scratch.
Perfect Partners
This sauce goes great with a simple green salad, the fresh crunch works so well against the rich sauce. And don't forget good bread, everyone wants to wipe their plates clean and get every drop of that gravy.
Kitchen Essentials
My Dutch oven does the heavy lifting for this recipe, giving that perfect all-around heat. When life gets crazy, I'll throw everything in my slow cooker instead and it turns out just as tasty. You'll get great results either way.
New Takes on Tradition
This might not match my Italian grandma's exact Sunday sauce, but pot roast brings its own kind of magic. I love how it makes such a fancy-tasting sauce without spending a fortune. The meat just falls apart and melts into every spoonful, making everything taste so rich.
Why I Love Pot Roast
Pot roast has become my go-to meat for this sauce. During that slow cooking time, it breaks down into soft strands that soak up all the flavors. It costs way less than short ribs but still gives you that wow factor when you serve it.
Little Touches of Magic
I sometimes drop in a tiny star anise that adds subtle warmth. A good pour of red wine builds complexity, and fresh herbs brighten everything up. When you finish with that swirl of cream and cheese, the sauce turns silky smooth.
Any Day is Sunday
We call it Sunday sauce but honestly, it works for any day you want comfort food. It's great for family dinners, holiday get-togethers, or when friends come over. Making it ahead takes all the stress out of hosting.
Creating Memories
This sauce means more to me than just food on a plate. It brings people together around my table, creating those nights where we talk for hours and nobody checks their phone. Each time I make it, I remember why sharing meals with people I care about matters so much.
Save it
Common Questions
- → Can I use a slow cooker instead?
- Absolutely! Set it on low for 8-10 hours until the meat falls apart. Just move everything to the stove when it's time to mix in pasta and cream.
- → What's the point of star anise?
- It brings a hidden layer of flavor to meat sauces. You can skip it, but many Italian-American families use it as their secret touch.
- → Is it okay to cook this beforehand?
- You can make the sauce up to 3 days early and warm it up later. Just wait to add the cream and butter when you're mixing with freshly cooked pasta.
- → What if I don't want to use wine?
- Just add more beef broth with 2 tablespoons of balsamic vinegar instead. You'll still get that rich flavor.
- → Do I really need San Marzano tomatoes?
- They're naturally sweeter and less tart than regular tomatoes, which makes your sauce taste better. Regular crushed tomatoes work too if that's all you've got.