Save it
Nothing hits the spot quite like sinking your teeth into a hot, crispy Reuben sandwich. When that buttery rye bread gives way to juicy corned beef, zingy sauerkraut, gooey Swiss cheese, and that creamy thousand island dressing - it's pure magic. This classic combo has kept folks coming back for more ever since it first showed up in NYC way back when.
Whenever I whip these up during family get-togethers, they're gone in seconds. The moment that rye bread starts toasting in butter, everyone magically appears in the kitchen.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Seeded Rye Bread: Go for hearty slices with plenty of seeds; you'll need something substantial to handle all the fillings
- Corned Beef: Ask for fresh-cut at the deli, not too thin or thick
- Sauerkraut: The stuff in the refrigerated section tastes better and has more crunch
- Swiss Cheese: Grate it yourself for smoother melting than the packaged slices
- Thousand Island Dressing: Store-bought works great, but homemade adds a special touch
- Butter: Skip the salted kind so you can manage the sandwich's saltiness yourself
Step-by-Step Preparation Guide
- Step 1: Building Your Sandwich
- - Don't use cold ingredients straight from the fridge
- Stack everything like this: bread first, then cheese, dressing, corned beef, kraut
- Push down slightly to hold it together without crushing
- Spread butter completely across the outer sides of your bread - Step 2: Nailing the Cooking Method
- - Set your pan to medium heat (hot will ruin it)
- Drop the sandwich in butter-side touching the pan
- Use your spatula to apply light pressure for better browning
- Wait until it's golden (roughly 3 minutes on each side)
- Turn it over with care to keep everything inside
My grandma always piled extra sauerkraut on her Reubens. She'd talk about its tummy-friendly qualities and share tales of her mom fermenting cabbage in wooden casks at home.
Getting The Heat Just Right
Nailing your Reuben comes down to watching your heat. Cook it too hot and you'll end up with charred bread and cold cheese inside. Too low and you'll get a mushy mess. I've learned that sticking with medium heat lets the cheese get all melty while giving the bread that perfect golden crunch.
Keeping It Fresh and Planning Ahead
Reubens taste way better right after cooking, but you can get things ready beforehand. Keep all your stuff separate in the fridge, and don't forget to let your corned beef warm up a bit before making your sandwich. It's a tiny thing that makes a big difference in how it turns out.
Mix It Up Your Way
The traditional Reuben rocks all on its own, but feel free to switch things around. You can swap in pastrami for a deeper smoky taste, or add different mustards with your thousand island. Some folks tell me they use turkey for something lighter, though the sandwich purists might not call that a real Reuben anymore.
Common Questions
- → What’s the best bread for making a Reuben?
- Stick with dark or plain rye bread. Its sturdy texture and flavor hold everything together perfectly.
- → Is it okay to swap corned beef with pastrami?
- Absolutely! Pastrami works well and adds another layer of flavor to the sandwich.
- → How can I keep my Reuben from getting soggy?
- Draining your sauerkraut well and toasting the sandwich properly will help keep the bread crispy.
- → Which cheese works best in a Reuben?
- Go for Swiss cheese. It melts beautifully and its creamy, mild flavor is the perfect match.
- → Can I prepare this sandwich in advance?
- It’s best fresh, but you can prep the filling and store it separately until ready to toast.