Save it
Our kitchen gets so cozy when this creamy Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese bakes in the oven. I've tweaked this dish for ages and it really combines all the best parts of comfort food. Butternut squash's gentle sweetness works wonders with the bold Gruyère flavor, making each forkful something special. My kids start asking for this the minute autumn arrives, and I totally get why.
The Magic Behind This Dish
This goes way beyond regular mac and cheese. Through lots of kitchen testing, I found that butternut squash creates this amazing smooth texture that's totally game-changing. The nutty flavor from Gruyère really stands out, and I sneak kale in so cleverly nobody realizes they're getting veggies. You'll definitely make this your favorite when you need something warm and tasty.
Ingredients You'll Want
- Black pepper, 1/2 teaspoon: Just grind it fresh for better taste.
- Salt, 1 teaspoon: Kosher or sea salt works great to bring out flavors.
- Monterey Jack cheese, 1 1/2 cups: Grate it yourself (1 cup for the mix, 1/2 cup on top). Store-bought shredded stuff doesn't melt quite right.
- Fresh chives, 1/4 cup: Cut them super tiny. Try just 1 tablespoon if using dried ones. Green onions work too.
- Two big eggs: Get them to room temp and beat them till they're foamy. They hold everything together and make it fluffy.
- Cold mashed potatoes, 3 cups: Leftovers work great. If you make fresh ones, let them cool down completely so they mix better.
- Sour cream, 1/2 cup: You can skip this if you want, but full-fat gives the best results when serving.
How To Make It
- Get Everything Ready
- Put your oven rack right in the middle and turn it to 400°F (200°C). Spray your mini muffin tin really well with cooking spray, getting into all the little corners of each cup.
- Mix It All Together
- Take a big bowl and stir your cold potatoes with the beaten eggs until they're just combined. Toss in 1 cup of your cheese, the chives, salt, and pepper. Stir gently till everything's mixed in, but don't overdo it.
- Get Them In The Tin
- Use a cookie scoop or a couple spoons to put the mixture in each muffin cup. Fill them up to the top, about 2 tablespoons each. They should be full but not spilling over. Smooth the tops with a spoon. Sprinkle the rest of your cheese on each one.
- Cook Them Just Right
- Let them bake for 15-20 minutes, turning the pan around halfway. You want the tops golden and edges crispy. The cheese should be all melty and a bit brown. Stick a knife in the middle - it should come out clean.
- Finish And Enjoy
- Take them out and wait exactly 5 minutes - this helps them set up. Run a plastic knife around each one to loosen it, then put them on a plate. Add more chives on top if you want and serve them hot with sour cream on the side.
My Cooking Tips
Don't cheap out on the cheese, it really matters. Keep an eye on your pasta or you'll end up with soggy shells. If you can't do nuts, try pepitas, they're awesome. Always give it a few minutes to sit after baking so the sauce gets nice and thick.
Ways To Switch It Up
Add some cooked chicken if you want more protein. Go for fresh spinach when you don't have kale around. Try smoky gouda instead - my little ones absolutely love that version. Add some crunchy bacon on top for special dinners or just pile on extra cheese if you want to keep it simple.
Fast Answers You Might Need
It tastes like smooth butternut with rich cheese and hints of garlic. You can totally leave out the greens or swap them for something else. Leftover portions stay good in the freezer for 3 months. If you're vegan, just use your favorite non-dairy cheese and swap in some cashew cream instead of yogurt - works great.
Save it
Common Questions
- → Why mix butternut squash into pasta?
It gives you a creamy texture, a touch of sweetness, and added vitamins while cutting back on how much cheese you need. The sauce turns silky and smooth.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
You sure can! Assemble it, freeze for up to three months, then bake when ready. Or bake first, freeze, and thaw before reheating. Handy for planning ahead.
- → Why does this need Greek yogurt?
Greek yogurt ups the protein and gives a tangy flavor while keeping things rich and smooth. Swap for cream cheese or sour cream if you like.
- → Why is fresh cheese better?
Shredded cheese in bags often has stuff added to keep it from sticking, which can mess with how it melts. Grating it fresh makes the sauce smoother.
- → Can I skip the kale?
Of course! Kale is optional. For a twist, use spinach or broccoli instead, or just leave it out if greens aren’t for you.