Save it
This classic comfort dish gives you tender noodles and a silky, rich cheese blend like the one grandma made. You’ll get that awesome combo of stretchy, melted center and a crunchy, browned top. Simple stuff and careful baking are the trick. Pop it in the oven, and in about an hour, you’ve got a meal everyone loves for family night or special get-togethers.
Why You'll Love Making This
This one skips any weird powders—just real cheese and pantry basics. The sauce turns out creamy every time, and the baked top is that perfect crispy bite. It won't break the bank since it's all everyday ingredients. Great for prepping ahead if you’re busy or feeding a crowd, too.
What You Need
- Cheese: 5 cups shredded sharp cheddar, split up for inside and topping
- Hot Sauce: Add a dash or two if you want extra kick (totally up to you)
- Pasta: 1 pound elbows or another small noodle
- Seasonings: You’ll need a teaspoon each of salt and pepper, plus half a teaspoon paprika
- Flour: 1/4 cup to thicken things up
- Butter: 1/2 cup unsalted, split between pasta and sauce
- Milk: 3 cups whole, warmed up a bit
Step-by-Step Easy Directions
- Get It Baked
- Pour everything in your baking dish. Sprinkle with that last bit of cheese. Bake about 25 to 30 minutes, until you see it bubbling and golden.
- Add the Cheese
- Toss 4 cups cheese and all those seasonings into the sauce. Stir until everything’s smooth and melted in. Fold in the pasta you already cooked.
- Sauce Time
- Use the rest of the butter and melt it in a big pot. Add in the flour and cook, stirring for a few minutes until it’s just turning tan. Slowly pour in warm milk, stirring to keep it lump-free.
- Pasta First
- Cook elbows until just firm, about 8 minutes. Drain, toss with a spoonful of butter. Heat oven to 375°F while you do this.
Save it
Why This One’s a Standout
This meal wins by keeping it simple—real cheese, a creamy sauce you can’t mess up, and a golden top that’s hard to resist. No weird ingredients needed, just comforting, everyday stuff that everyone digs. The sauce is nice and smooth, pasta stands up (not mushy), and the cheesy top is what everyone fights for.
Cheese Sauce Tricks
You can totally make smooth cheese sauce with these no-stress tips. Keep your stove at medium-low heat so it doesn’t scorch. Pour milk in a little at a time while stirring so you’re not stuck with lumps. Shred your own cheese if you can—it melts way better. Bring cheese out of the fridge and let it warm up before adding. If your sauce suddenly gets grainy, pour in a little warm milk and stir gently—it usually gets creamy again.
Switch It Up
Once you nail the basic method, play around with extras. Try swapping in some Monterey Jack with the cheddar, or sprinkle panko breadcrumbs on top for crunchy bites. Toss in some cooked bacon chunks or chopped jalapeños. Like more heat? Add more hot sauce or use pepper jack. Just keep your noodle and sauce measurements steady.
How to Serve
Spoon this up piping hot right out of the oven as the main event with a green salad, or dish it up alongside ham or meatloaf. It’s a hit for potlucks, holidays, or just a cozy Sunday meal. If you’re feeding a crew, you can easily double it—just grab a bigger pan and tack on 5–10 more minutes in the oven.
Save Leftovers and Heat Them Up
Pop extra servings in the fridge, covered, for up to 4 days. When reheating, pour in a splash of milk and go low and slow—use the oven or microwave. Stir here and there to keep it saucy. For best texture, heat up just what you need instead of the whole pan. If the noodles soaked up all the sauce in the fridge, that added milk will bring the creamy bite right back.
Save it
Common Questions
- → Can I use different cheese?
Jack turns out mild, Gouda’s super creamy, sharp cheddar brings zing. Playing with cheese combos is fun—try half cheddar, half gouda. But skip those bagged shreds; they don’t melt as nice. Just grab a grater and go fresh and your cheese will melt dreamy-smooth.
- → Need it gluten-free?
Grab gluten-free pasta and a blend of GF flour. Rice shapes need a little less time boiling. Don’t forget to peek at your cheese labels since some have starch added. You might want a splash more milk because gluten-free flour soaks things up. Some people go heavy on the cheese for an even cozier texture.
- → Can I make it ahead?
You bet! Put it together the night before and let it chill in your fridge. Pull it out a good half hour before it hits the oven. It might bake a little longer since it’s cold. A lot of folks double up—bake one, freeze the second. See if the sauce feels thick when you reheat, and add milk if you need. Sprinkle the topping right before baking so it stays crisp.
- → What makes it better?
Top it with crispy bacon to get a good crunch. Mix breadcrumbs with melted butter so they turn golden in the oven. Try jalapeños if you want a little heat. Even slow-cooked onions are winners. Throw your toppings on after everything’s mixed so they bake up just right.
- → How do I warm leftovers?
Pop leftovers in the oven with a splash of milk and cover up, so the top stays nice. The microwave’s quick but go slow and stir a lot so the sauce stays creamy. Add a little milk as you go. Want the crispiest top? Stick it under the broiler for a quick finish.
Final Thoughts
If cheesy goodness is your thing, check out how easy broccoli cheese casserole is. Garlic cheese bread’s another winner. Both give your table big comfort vibes!